| Fight | Bryce* 11-13 | Brenden 12-12 | Buju 12-12 |
| Bellator 172 | |||
| Fedor Emelianenko vs. Matt Mitrione | Mitrione | Mitrione | Mitrione |
| Josh Thomson vs Patricky Freire | Thomson | Thomson | Freire |
| Josh Koscheck vs. Mauricio Alonso | Koscheck | Koscheck | Alonso |
| Cheick Kongo vs. Oli Thompson | Kongo | Kongo | Kongo |
| UFC Halifax | |||
| Derrick Lewis vs. Travis Browne | Lewis | Lewis | Lewis |
| Johny Hendricks vs. Hector Lombard | Lombard | Lombard | Lombard |
| Cezar Ferreira vs. Elias Theodoreau | Theodoreau | Theodoreau | Theodoreau |
| Sara McMann vs. Gina Mazany | McMann | McMann | McMann |
| Paul Felder vs. Alessandro Ricci | Felder | Felder | Felder |
| Carla Esparza vs. Randa Markos | Esparza | Esparza | Esparza |
*Denotes 2016 Untitled MMA Annual Picks Champion